Why do two people face the same stressful event yet respond in completely different ways – one spiraling into anxiety, the other shrugging it off? The answer lies not in the event itself, but in how each person thinks about it. This is the central insight of Cognitive Behaviour Therapy (CBT), which is built on a biopsychosocial model of human emotion and behavior. Understanding this model – and the theory of causation behind it – is key to understanding how CBT works and why it is one of the most evidence-based psychotherapies available today.
Table of Contents
- What is the biopsychosocial model?
- How CBT uses the biopsychosocial model
- The theory of causation in CBT: beliefs drive consequences
- Albert Ellis’s ABC model explained
- A – activating event
- B – beliefs
- C – consequences
- A practical example
- From ABC to ABCDE: disputing irrational beliefs
- Why beliefs sit at the intersection of biology, psychology, and society
- The significance of this theory for understanding psychological distress
What is the biopsychosocial model?
The biopsychosocial model was first proposed by psychiatrist George Engel in 1977 as a more complete alternative to the purely biomedical model of illness. According to a review published in the Annals of Family Medicine, the model is both a philosophy of clinical care and a practical clinical guide – one that understands suffering, disease, and illness as shaped by multiple levels of organization, from the molecular to the societal.
Rather than attributing mental health difficulties to a single cause, the biopsychosocial model recognizes three interacting domains:
- Biological factors – genetic predispositions, neurochemistry, brain structure, and physical health
- Psychological factors – thoughts, beliefs, emotions, coping styles, and cognitive patterns
- Social factors – relationships, cultural context, socioeconomic conditions, and life stressors
Research published in the Indian Journal of Psychological Medicine reinforces this point clearly: psychiatric disorders are not the result of a linear cause-and-effect medical model, but arise from a complex, circular network of multiple causes and effects. No single factor operates in isolation. A person’s genetic vulnerability, the way they interpret events, and the social environment they live in all feed into one another – and all contribute to how psychological distress develops and is maintained.
How CBT uses the biopsychosocial model
CBT is firmly grounded in this model. It does not ignore biology – it acknowledges that factors such as genetics, brain chemistry, and physical health contribute to a person’s vulnerability. However, it particularly focuses on the psychological component: the beliefs and interpretations a person holds about their experiences.
As described in The Biopsychosocial Model of Health and Disease, the core theory underpinning CBT – as stated by its founder Aaron Beck – is that cognitions cause both affect and behavior. This is not a trivial claim. It means that working directly with thought patterns is a legitimate and effective route to changing emotional distress and maladaptive behavior. CBT interventions are therefore designed to target the psychological layer of the biopsychosocial model: identifying distorted or unhelpful thinking and replacing it with more accurate, flexible thinking.
This approach also has documented biological effects. A review in Frontiers in Pain Research found that CBT can reverse some neuronal changes associated with chronic conditions, including post-treatment increases in prefrontal cortex activity – areas associated with cognitive appraisal – and reductions in somatosensory cortex activity. The psychological intervention, in other words, produces real biological changes.
The theory of causation in CBT: beliefs drive consequences
At the heart of CBT’s theory of causation is a deceptively simple idea: it is not situations themselves that cause emotional distress, but the beliefs we hold about those situations. The external event – a failed exam, a rejection, a difficult conversation – is the trigger. But the emotional consequence – anxiety, shame, anger – is shaped by the beliefs that sit between the event and the response.
This insight has ancient philosophical roots. Albert Ellis, who developed Rational Emotive Behaviour Therapy (REBT) – widely regarded as the original form of CBT – drew on Stoic philosophers like Epictetus and Marcus Aurelius, who taught that it is our judgments about events, not events themselves, that disturb us. Ellis formally articulated this in a psychological framework with his ABC model.
According to the Albert Ellis Institute, REBT is the first form of cognitive-behavioural therapy, and its ABC model is arguably the foundation for the broader CBT family. Both rational and irrational beliefs develop through a combination of genetic predisposition and environmental influences – including parenting and early life experiences – which is consistent with the biopsychosocial framework.
Albert Ellis’s ABC model explained
The ABC model provides a clear, structured way to understand the causal chain from experience to emotional outcome. Each letter represents a distinct stage:
A – activating event
This is the situation, circumstance, or trigger. It could be an external event (a colleague’s critical comment) or an internal one (a memory or a physical sensation). The activating event sets the process in motion but, critically, does not directly cause the emotional response.
B – beliefs
This is where the core of the model lies. Beliefs are the thoughts, evaluations, and interpretations a person applies to the activating event. As explained in Positive Psychology’s review of the ABC model, external events (A) do not cause emotions (C) – beliefs (B), and particularly irrational beliefs, do. The model distinguishes between two types of beliefs: rational beliefs, which are flexible, realistic, and goal-consistent, and irrational beliefs, which are rigid, demanding, and self-defeating.
The Albert Ellis Institute identifies four core irrational beliefs that drive emotional disturbance: demandingness (rigid “must” and “should” thinking), awfulizing or catastrophizing, frustration intolerance, and global negative ratings of self, others, or the world. Mediational research has confirmed that demandingness is the central irrational belief – it gives rise to the others.
C – consequences
These are the emotional and behavioral outcomes that follow from the beliefs held about the activating event. Rational beliefs lead to healthy, proportionate emotional responses – disappointment, concern, regret – which support adaptive behavior. Irrational beliefs, by contrast, produce unhealthy emotional consequences such as severe anxiety, depression, rage, or shame, along with behaviors like avoidance, aggression, or withdrawal.
A practical example
Consider two people who both receive critical feedback from a manager at work. Person A holds the belief: “I made a mistake, and I’d prefer not to, but mistakes are part of learning.” They feel disappointed briefly, then refocus on improvement. Person B holds the belief: “I must perform perfectly at all times – this feedback proves I am incompetent.” They feel intense shame and anxiety, avoid future tasks, and ruminate for days. The activating event was identical. The beliefs – and therefore the consequences – were entirely different.
From ABC to ABCDE: disputing irrational beliefs
The ABC model doesn’t stop at identifying the problem – it points directly toward the solution. In Ellis’s own words, the model is followed in therapy by D – the disputing of irrational beliefs – until the person arrives at E, a new and more rational set of beliefs. This is why the model is often extended to ABCDE.
Disputation involves using logical questioning, empirical evidence, and pragmatic reasoning to challenge the validity and usefulness of irrational beliefs. A therapist might ask: “Where is the evidence that you must always perform perfectly?” or “Is it truly catastrophic to receive feedback, or is it uncomfortable but manageable?” Over time, this process helps the client replace rigid demands with flexible preferences, and global self-condemnation with more nuanced and self-compassionate thinking.
This is not simply positive thinking. Research published in Frontiers in Psychology highlights that irrational beliefs function as cognitive vulnerability factors that, when activated by events, increase the probability of dysfunctional emotional states. Changing these beliefs is therefore a genuine mechanism of therapeutic change – not a superficial reframe.
Why beliefs sit at the intersection of biology, psychology, and society
The elegance of the biopsychosocial model in CBT is that beliefs don’t arise in a vacuum. A person’s tendency toward certain irrational beliefs is shaped by their biological temperament and genetic makeup, their psychological history and early learning experiences, and the social and cultural messages they have absorbed over a lifetime. A person raised in an environment where achievement was conditional on approval may develop deeply held demandingness beliefs. Someone with a biological vulnerability to anxiety may be more prone to catastrophizing.
As outlined in a comprehensive theoretical review in Psychological Medicine, social factors causally interact with psychological processes by regulating demands and available resources. Cultural norms, discrimination, poverty, and social exclusion all shape the psychological terrain in which beliefs form. This means effective CBT therapy does not simply challenge thoughts in isolation – it situates them within the full biopsychosocial context of the person’s life.
The biopsychosocial model also explains why the same intervention may work differently for different people. Research in Frontiers in Psychology describes how even two people presenting with the same complaint may have entirely different networks of beliefs, behaviors, and biological responses underlying their distress – requiring individually tailored approaches rather than one-size-fits-all treatment protocols.
The significance of this theory for understanding psychological distress
CBT’s theory of causation carries an important and empowering message: because emotional distress is mediated by beliefs, and because beliefs can be identified and changed, people are not helpless in the face of adversity. The environment may not always be controllable. Biology may present challenges. But the cognitive layer – the beliefs, interpretations, and evaluations – is accessible and modifiable.
This doesn’t mean emotional pain is simply a matter of “thinking correctly.” The biopsychosocial model ensures that CBT remains grounded in the full complexity of human experience. Biological vulnerabilities are real. Social hardship is real. But between those forces and their emotional consequences sits the crucial, changeable layer of belief – and that is precisely where CBT intervenes.
What do you think? If your emotional responses are shaped more by your beliefs than by events themselves, what does that mean for how much agency you have over your own mental health? And how might the social environment a person grows up in – the messages they receive about worth, success, or failure – shape the irrational beliefs they carry into adulthood?
References
- https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1466742/
- https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6875848/
- https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK552030/
- https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7728165/
- https://albertellis.org/rebt-therapy-in-the-context-of-modern-psychological-research/
- https://positivepsychology.com/albert-ellis-abc-model-rebt-cbt/
- https://psychwire.com/free-resources/q-and-a/83lt4s/understanding-rational-emotive-behavior-therapy
- https://albertellis.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/Emotional-Disturbance-and-Its-Treatment-in-a-Nutshell-ABCs-.pdf
- https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10957667/
- https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10755226/
- https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2022.1002849/full
Leave a Reply