Most of us carry emotional patterns we didn’t consciously choose – fears of rejection, difficulty expressing anger, or a tendency to withdraw when things get tense. These patterns often trace back further than we realize, rooted in early relationships and unresolved feelings we learned, early on, to push away. David Malan, a British psychodynamic therapist and researcher who spent decades at the Tavistock Clinic in London, built a structured framework to make sense of exactly this. His two conceptual triangles – the triangle of conflict and the triangle of persons – offer therapists a precise map for identifying and resolving these buried emotional conflicts, even within the tight constraints of short-term therapy.
Table of Contents
- Who was David Malan?
- The two triangles: an overview
- The triangle of conflict
- Hidden feeling or impulse
- Anxiety
- Defense
- The triangle of persons
- Current significant others (O)
- The therapist and transference (T)
- Past figures and parents (P)
- Linking the two triangles: the heart of Malan’s method
- Legacy and contemporary use
Who was David Malan?
David Huntingford Malan (1922-2020) was a British psychoanalytic practitioner and researcher best known for his work on brief psychodynamic therapy. After joining the Tavistock Clinic in 1956, he dedicated his career to a question that ran against the grain of traditional analysis: could deep, lasting psychological change happen in a short time? His research repeatedly said yes. In 1979, he published Individual Psychotherapy and the Science of Psychodynamics, the book that introduced his now-famous two-triangle model to the wider therapeutic world. His goal, stated plainly, was to find the most effective treatment that could help the most patients in the shortest possible time – without sacrificing depth.
Malan was also a rigorous scientist. He insisted on long-term follow-ups to measure whether therapy had produced genuine, lasting change – not just surface relief. His findings challenged what he called the “myth of superficiality” – the widespread belief among critics that brief therapy could only produce shallow results with mildly troubled patients. His data showed otherwise.
The two triangles: an overview
Malan’s two triangles – the triangle of conflict and the triangle of persons – work together as a unified framework. One maps what is happening inside the person; the other maps where those dynamics show up in relationships. Used side by side, they give a therapist a real-time picture of a client’s emotional life and a direction for intervention. Malan himself described them as tools that, together, could inform almost every move a therapist makes – with skill lying in knowing which part of which triangle is most relevant at any given moment.
The triangle of conflict
The triangle of conflict addresses the internal psychological mechanics behind emotional distress. It has three points: hidden feeling or impulse, anxiety, and defense. Each plays a distinct role in a repeating cycle that keeps people stuck.
Hidden feeling or impulse
At the base – or apex when the triangle is inverted, as Malan intended – sits the hidden feeling. These are the raw emotional experiences that a person has learned not to fully acknowledge: anger toward someone they love, grief that was never expressed, a longing for closeness that feels dangerous to admit. According to research on emotion and adaptive action tendencies, these feelings are not pathological in themselves – they are normal human responses. Anger mobilizes us to set limits; sadness allows us to grieve; joy reinforces meaningful action. The problem arises when these feelings were threatening to express in earlier relationships, making them a source of internal conflict rather than useful signals.
Anxiety
When a hidden feeling starts to surface, it triggers anxiety – the mind’s internal alarm. This anxiety is not a response to an external threat but to an internal one: the fear that feeling or expressing this emotion will lead to rejection, punishment, or loss of control. The anxiety serves a protective function, alerting the person to back away from whatever is rising up. In therapy, this anxiety is often visible in the body – a tightening of the chest, shallow breathing, sudden topic changes – before it ever reaches words.
Defense
To manage the anxiety, the person employs defenses: unconscious strategies that keep the threatening feeling out of awareness. As outlined in research on psychodynamic technique, these defenses can take many forms – repression, projection, denial, intellectualization, or rationalization – each working to push the feeling back below the surface. Defenses are not inherently bad; they helped the person manage unbearable situations in the past. But when they become rigid and automatic, they prevent emotional processing and keep distress alive in the form of symptoms: depression, relationship difficulties, chronic anxiety, or unexplained physical complaints.
The three elements form a feedback loop: the hidden feeling surfaces → anxiety spikes → a defense activates to suppress both. This sequence can repeat dozens of times within a single therapy session, often in a matter of seconds. The therapist’s job is to interrupt this loop – not by eliminating defenses, but by helping the client become aware of them, understand their cost, and gradually lower the need for them.
The triangle of persons
The triangle of persons shifts the focus from internal dynamics to relational patterns. It asks: where, and with whom, does this emotional conflict play out? The three points are the current significant other (O), the therapist or transference (T), and the parent or past figure (P).
Current significant others (O)
This point represents people in the client’s present life – a partner, a boss, a close friend – with whom the same emotional pattern tends to recur. Someone with a hidden feeling of anger that triggers anxiety and gets suppressed through withdrawal will often show this exact pattern in their most important relationships. The conflict does not stay neatly inside the person; it shapes how they relate.
The therapist and transference (T)
The therapeutic relationship is a particularly valuable point on this triangle precisely because it happens in real time. Clients often recreate, with their therapist, the same relational patterns they use with others. A client who fears judgment may become evasive in sessions; one who suppresses needs may be relentlessly accommodating. Malan identified the therapeutic relationship as having three significant poles, with transference serving as a live demonstration of the client’s core conflict – something that can be named and worked with directly, in the room, rather than reconstructed from outside accounts.
Past figures and parents (P)
At the inverted apex of the triangle of persons sits the past – usually parental figures or early caregivers with whom the original emotional patterns were formed. The anxiety around expressing anger, grief, or need rarely develops in adulthood; it almost always has earlier roots. A child who learned that expressing sadness brought withdrawal rather than comfort, or that anger led to punishment, adapted by suppressing those feelings. Decades later, the adaptation continues even when the original conditions are long gone.
Linking the two triangles: the heart of Malan’s method
The real power of Malan’s framework lies in connecting the two triangles. A therapist using this approach is doing more than tracking what a client feels (triangle of conflict) – they are tracing where those feelings appear and where they originated (triangle of persons). As one analysis of psychodynamic formulation notes, the triangles offer a consistent and clinically applicable way of making sense of what clients bring to the room – one flexible enough to work across varied presentations.
In practice, a therapist might notice that a client becomes deflecting and self-deprecating (defense) whenever they start to talk about a need for closeness (hidden feeling) – and that this happens both with their partner (O), in the session itself (T), and, upon exploration, with a parent who was emotionally unavailable (P). This cross-triangle linking – connecting the pattern across time and relationship – is what Malan’s research found to correlate with good therapeutic outcomes. The more consistently a therapist could link transference to childhood experience, the more substantial the change.
This is also what made Malan’s approach suited to time-limited work. When a therapist has a structured map of what the conflict is and where it shows up, they can work with focus and efficiency. Sessions are not open-ended explorations but directed interventions guided by the triangles at every step. The therapy is time-limited – typically up to 30 sessions – and focused on a central theme agreed upon with the client at the outset. Anything outside that focus is set aside; anything related is examined closely.
Legacy and contemporary use
Malan’s triangles did not remain confined to his own clinical work. They became core components of Experiential Short-Term Dynamic Psychotherapy (E-STDP) and are embedded in several contemporary approaches, including Affect Phobia Therapy and Regulation-Focused Psychotherapy for Children (RFP-C), which adapts the conflict triangle for younger clients with externalizing behaviors. They are also widely used in training new therapists – helping clinicians learn to track what is happening in a session moment by moment, rather than reacting instinctively or defaulting to advice-giving.
That said, the model has attracted criticism. Critics have warned against mechanical application – using the triangles as a checklist rather than a living clinical tool, which can tip therapy toward intellectual analysis at the expense of genuine emotional engagement. Others have noted a limited base of large-scale randomized controlled trial evidence directly validating the foundational model itself, though derivative therapies built on its principles have shown promising results in smaller studies.
What remains undisputed is the framework’s longevity and clarity. Malan set out to make psychodynamic thinking teachable, rigorous, and practical – and by most accounts, he succeeded. The triangles remain one of the most widely referenced conceptual tools in dynamic psychotherapy training, valued precisely because they are, as one scholar put it, “deceptively simple but effective in approaching clinical situations no matter how convoluted.”
What do you think? If you reflect on a recurring difficulty in your own relationships, can you identify what feeling might be sitting beneath the surface – and what you tend to do to avoid it? And does knowing that these patterns often trace back to early experiences change how you think about your current struggles?
References
- https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10387422/
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_H._Malan
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malan_triangles
- https://istdpinstitute.com/2012/the-triangle-of-conflict/
- https://www.longdom.org/open-access-pdfs/ten-principles-to-guide-psychodynamic-technique-with-defense-mechanisms-an-examination-of-theory-research-and-clinical-implication-2161-0487-1000288.pdf
- https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/0240/a3d17bdb7a6655dc2b703e4132ab9880735b.pdf
- https://alchetron.com/David-Malan-(psychotherapist)
Leave a Reply